Why should this blog exist?
There are so many people out there writing about marketing. Neither you nor I need another person reporting news, writing case studies, or transcribing interviews. So I won't.
My goal is to take a few of those stories and ask, "So what" and "what now." Hopefully by putting those questions in context and in writing, I can help myself and you draw more meaning from it all.
Turns out in Twitter your Muted Words filter doesn't apply to ads.
This seems important since lots of people use this feature for things way more important than spoilers.
But also, hey, if you're ever feeling devious... here's your Hall Pass I guess.
This is just a heads up to read the tweet thread below. In ham-fisted ways, I’ve tried to say the current MarTech ecosystem feels like organic social reach did in 2012, and that it feels like the lead up to the subprime mortgage crisis.
This guy though, he’s on a whole other level. This well researched, technical-yet-digestible, multimedia case should make heads turn. Read this and you’ll be the smartest person on the topic in any room you walk in to.Read More
This topic is a confluence of weedy tech stuff and public policy. Both passion points for me. Which means there’s a high risk I turn this into a 5,000 word monster. So I’m going to go short.
You may have heard that Facebook recently reached a settlement about what kind of targeting it allows people to use for protected categories like jobs, housing, and credit. If you haven’t heard about it, read this Wired piece.
Now you can’t target ads in those categories based on things like age, gender, race, and zip code.
Ok. Great. I’m a racist landlord and now I can’t create an exclusionary targeting audience of people with a Hispanic “ethnic affinity.” Everybody wins right?
Wrong. Because things like this are what happens when journalists, lawyers, and activists don’t understand how modern advertising actually works. Nobody’s saying — or even asking — the actually important thing.
Is Facebook rewiring its ad platform to prevent the algorithms from auto-optimizing ad performance based on those criteria? Because, in terms of accomplishing an ultimate objective of people seeing job, housing, and credit opportunities at relatively equal rates, ad targeting isn’t even all that impactful.
It’s the conversion optimization algorithms that really determine who actually sees the ads. Heck, Facebook even has this whole advertiser evaluation thing that’s basically 50%, “Are you micromanaging or are you setting broad parameters and just letting the algorithms do the real work?”
So the TLDR here is, Without putting constraints on how the delivery of ads are optimized, this is a showpiece concession."
So, if the targeting concessions won’t have a huge impact on outcomes, why the focus? Why the celebration? Because modern marketing is such an opaque, weedy, specialized field that it can be hard for “commoners” to really understand what lever to apply pressure to. Because Targeting is the thing with a public-facing UI that people can screen shot. Because it’s easy to communicate in the :45 news segment.
In other words, it’s an effigy. A stand-in for the real problem. And all we got is Facebook agreeing to let people burn the effigy in public while the real problem lives on in the background.
And if even Wired can’t get it right, we’re probably in trouble.Read More
Things are sideways, upside down, and underwater in Ad Land. And we’ve all kind of known it. But what happens next? I’d like to propose a thought exercise.Read More
Today ad tech feels a lot like social media marketing did in 2012. A correction is coming. What happens if the targeting, personalization, and attribution capabilities we have now just… go away?Read More
How many articles have you read about marketing attribution this year? Lots. How many made a great case for the importance of it? All is them. How many made your feel behind the times? Most. How many gave you even a single really actionable step to get better? ("Buy my SaaS!" doesn't count) Three? One? None?Read More
A lot has been made of Instagram co-opting Snapchat's Stories feature set. And while it's does matter, slaying Stories isn't how Facebook can slay Snapchat.Read More
A common practice in medical schools is to tell new students that half of what they learn won't be true by the time they graduate -- but nobody knows which half.Read More
I just saw an ad on a website that used my phone's camera to scroll AR-style around a 360° video. That is intrusive, unexpected, and creepy.Read More